How Are Investment Income and Withdrawals From a $10 Million Portfolio Taxed?
If you have a $10 million investment portfolio, you probably don't spend much time worrying about whether you can afford retirement.
But you may spend quite a bit of time wondering:
How much of my $10 million can I actually spend after taxes?
That's a different question.
A $10 million portfolio can potentially generate significant income. But the tax treatment of that income depends on where your money is invested, what type of income it produces, and which accounts you withdraw money from.
This is where retirement planning gets interesting.
I'm Charlie. I'm a CPA and CFP® professional, and I specialize in tax-efficient retirement planning. When I look at a $10 million portfolio, I don't just look at the investment return.
I look at what happens after taxes.
Because earning $500,000 and keeping $500,000 are two very different things.
How Is Investment Income From a $10 Million Portfolio Taxed?
The first thing to understand is that not all investment income is taxed the same way.
A $10 million portfolio might generate:
Interest
Dividends
Capital gains
Mutual fund distributions
Other investment income
The tax treatment can vary significantly depending on the type of income and the account holding the investment.
Interest income
Interest from taxable accounts is generally taxed as ordinary income.
For example, suppose part of your $10 million portfolio is invested in bonds or other investments generating $200,000 of interest.
That doesn't necessarily mean you pay a single flat tax rate on the $200,000.
Instead, the interest generally becomes part of your taxable income and is taxed according to your applicable federal income tax rates.
For someone with substantial income, this distinction matters.
Qualified dividends
Some dividends receive preferential federal tax treatment rather than being taxed at ordinary income tax rates.
That can make the type of investment income your portfolio produces an important part of tax planning.
Two portfolios could generate the same amount of cash but create very different tax bills.
Capital gains
Capital gains generally occur when you sell an investment for more than your tax basis.
For example, imagine you purchased an investment for $100,000 and later sell it for $250,000.
You don't generally have a $250,000 capital gain.
You have a $150,000 gain.
That distinction is important when you're creating retirement income from a large taxable portfolio.
And here's another important point:
You don't necessarily have to sell investments that have appreciated simply because you need cash.
The source of your retirement income—and the timing of sales—can become a major tax-planning decision.
What Happens When You Withdraw Money From a Traditional IRA or 401(k)?
Now let's say your $10 million portfolio isn't all sitting in a taxable brokerage account.
Maybe you have:
$4 million in traditional retirement accounts
$4 million in taxable investments
$2 million in Roth accounts
That is a very different tax situation.
Withdrawals from traditional IRAs and most traditional 401(k) accounts are generally taxable as ordinary income to the extent the money hasn't already been taxed.
So if you withdraw $300,000 from a traditional IRA, you don't generally get to treat that $300,000 as a capital gain just because you invested the money in stocks.
It's generally ordinary taxable income.
This is one reason I don't like thinking about a $10 million portfolio as one giant bucket of money.
The account type matters.
What About Roth Accounts?
Roth accounts can be extremely valuable from a retirement tax-planning perspective.
Qualified withdrawals from a Roth IRA are generally tax-free.
That means having money in different tax "buckets" can give you flexibility when you're deciding where your retirement income should come from.
For example, imagine you need $400,000 to support your lifestyle.
You could potentially take all $400,000 from a traditional IRA.
Or you might take some from a taxable account and some from a Roth account.
Or you might use another combination of income sources.
The "right" answer depends on your situation.
But that's the point.
Retirement income planning isn't simply about deciding how much money to withdraw. It's about deciding where to withdraw it from.
Does Selling Investments Create a Taxable Withdrawal?
This is another common source of confusion.
Suppose you have $5 million in a taxable brokerage account and sell $400,000 of investments.
That doesn't automatically mean you have $400,000 of taxable income.
Your taxable gain depends on your cost basis.
If the investments you're selling have a $250,000 cost basis, for example, you could have a $150,000 capital gain rather than $400,000 of taxable gain.
This is one reason tax-loss harvesting, gain management and thoughtful investment selection can become increasingly important as portfolios grow.
When you have $10 million, small tax differences can become very large dollar amounts.
What About Required Minimum Distributions?
Eventually, many retirees with traditional retirement accounts will have required minimum distributions, or RMDs.
RMDs generally become mandatory at the applicable starting age under current law, and taxable distributions from traditional retirement accounts generally count as taxable income.
This creates an interesting planning issue for someone with a large traditional retirement balance.
You may have accumulated millions of dollars in tax-deferred accounts because that was a smart decision during your working years.
But retirement is different.
Now you have to think about how—and when—that money eventually comes out.
That's why I believe tax planning should start before you are required to take money out.
Can You Reduce Taxes on a $10 Million Portfolio?
You probably can't eliminate taxes.
And that's not the goal.
The goal is to avoid paying more taxes than necessary over your lifetime.
That can involve looking at strategies such as:
Managing capital gains
Coordinating taxable and tax-deferred withdrawals
Using Roth conversions when appropriate
Managing the timing of retirement account distributions
Considering charitable giving strategies
Choosing which investments belong in which accounts
Using tax-loss harvesting when appropriate
Planning around future RMDs
Coordinating investment income with other sources of retirement income
The important word here is coordinating.
These decisions shouldn't happen in isolation.
For example, doing a Roth conversion might look attractive until you consider how it affects your overall tax situation.
Selling a highly appreciated investment might make sense from an investment perspective but create a significant tax bill.
Taking a large IRA withdrawal might give you plenty of cash but push more of your income into higher tax brackets.
The numbers need to be looked at together.
What Is the Tax Bill on a $10 Million Portfolio?
There isn't one universal answer.
A $10 million portfolio could produce very different tax bills depending on:
How the portfolio is invested
How much income it generates
How much is held in taxable accounts
How much is held in traditional retirement accounts
How much is held in Roth accounts
Your other sources of income
Your capital gains
Your deductions
Your state of residence
Your charitable giving
Your age and retirement timeline
That's why I don't think the best question is:
"How much can my $10 million portfolio generate?"
I'd rather ask:
"How much can I spend after taxes while still accomplishing everything I want my money to do?"
That's a much more useful number.
The Bottom Line
Having $10 million is an incredible financial accomplishment.
But once you reach that level of wealth, investment management and tax planning become increasingly connected.
Your portfolio isn't just an investment account.
It's potentially your retirement income, your family's wealth, your charitable legacy and your financial security for decades to come.
The goal isn't to avoid taxes at all costs.
The goal is to make smart decisions about when, where and how your money is taxed.
Because you've worked hard for your retirement.
You shouldn't pay Uncle Sam more than you have to.
I'm Charlie Horonzy, CFP®, CPA. I help pre-retirees and retirees develop tax-efficient retirement strategies so they can make informed decisions about their money—and focus on living their best lives.
If you have $10 million or more and you're wondering how much you can actually spend after taxes, it may be worth running the numbers before you start taking large withdrawals.
Stay Focused!
This article is for general educational purposes only and is not individualized investment, tax, or financial advice. Tax rules and individual circumstances vary.
Comments